This past quarter I took a course on writing a research paper on travel (it is one of two mandatory GEs for my college). I, of course, used this to my benefit and wrote about travel in baseball. As promised here is my essay below, with a complete MLA style works cited page. Please give me your feedback, I'd like to see if college is teaching me anything.
TA: Dixa Ramirez
Final Research Paper
5 June 2008
Baseball's International History
It seems that many nations that have a history of United States intervention and an imperial legacy of U.S. domination have also produced some of the Major League Baseball's best talents. It can be theorized that this is a direct result of the spread of the game of baseball by those who intervened in regions', such as the Dominican Republic, Japan, and Puerto Rico, sovereign affairs. Baseball has even changed and traveled within its host nation of the United States, and this case serves as a microcosm for the rest of the world. Perhaps more interestingly is the journey that baseball has made back to the United States through the players who have come to love the game in their own nations. This is of special relevance this year as baseball is fast approaching its last stint in the Olympics (Beijing) and the sport is two years removed from its first World Baseball Classic (WBC, a baseball tournament between 16 nations to replace Olympic Baseball) and just one year away from its next. Baseball has become an international pastime, and I will discuss how baseball has traveled by analyzing baseball histories of different nations, as well as their relations to the United States, and biographies of some of baseball's most relevant players from the regions.
Baseball within the United States has a storied history that few people agree upon. By the account of John Rosenburg, baseball historian, one of the recently popular ideas is that, baseball in the United States was developed in the 1800's as a game, similar to that of the British games cricket and rounders (Rosenburg 7). Baseball started as a simple diversion, and was equally as popular as cricket. However, according to Robert Edelman, University of California, San Diego, Professor of Russian and Sports History, after the Civil War (when the British backed the South) it became unpatriotic to support the game of cricket and baseball developed into the national pastime (Edelman 14 May, 2008). As baseball grew so did the opportunity for enterprise and the first professional team (members of which got paid), the Cincinnati Red Stockings, was formed in 1869 (Rosenburg 14). Once this club formed the National Association was created, and years later the American Association followed suite, the two of which are now Leagues, and constitute baseball's Major League. The game itself undergoes change on a constant basis, and as such a new issue of "the rules" is published every year. The basics, however, remain the same. Each team has a twenty-five-man roster, which opens up to a forty-man roster in September. A team taking the field consists of nine men, five infielders, three outfielders, and a pitcher. The significant difference between the two leagues is that the American League has allowed a "designated hitter" to bat for the pitcher since the 1980's.
The game of baseball went with imperial intentions of United States' travelers on their journeys and as such the game spread throughout the world, however bringing players back from these regions (especially if they were of color) was difficult. Most relevantly, was the spread of the game to the Nations of Japan and the Dominican Republic, as well as the region of Puerto Rico. These areas have produced many relevant baseball players throughout the history of the game. With that notion being kept in mind, it is extremely relevant to consider that prior to 1947 Major League Baseball (MLB) was not racially integrated. In 1947 Jackie Robinson joined the Brooklyn Dodgers from the Kansas City Monarchs (a club in the Negro Leagues) and baseball became integrated (under the watchful eye of Dodgers' General Manager Branch Rickey). This is not to say that people from other nations had not played in MLB prior to this, but they were "lighter-skinned" and had infact "played [at the Major League level] throughout the first half of the century," according to Alan Klein, who has studied baseball in the Dominican Republic for years (Klein 114).
Jackie Robinson was born in Georgia but soon moved to Los Angeles, California with his mother and siblings.
California is a microcosm for what happened the world over with the history of baseball, as players were developed in leagues derived from the MLB in this case the Pacific Coast League (PCL) and later moved to MLB. Four of baseball's most historic players (among many others) came from California, three of which came directly from the PCL, which was the west coast equivalent of the Majors. These four players were Ted Williams (San Diego Padres, later of the Red Sox), Joe DiMaggio (San Francisco Seals, later of the Yankees), Billy Martin (Oakland Oaks, later of the Yankees), and Jackie Robinson (who was not allowed in the PCL do to the color of his skin, but did play in the Negro leagues for the Kansas City Monarchs).
The PCL, during the 1930's to 1950's, functioned as today's Minor League equivalent, as players were brought up to the Majors after they had paid their dues. America is such a large nation that teams were only developed on the East Coast and Mid West, leaving the West Coast and South without teams, since travel was simply too costly and difficult. Baseball spread to the West Coast professionally in 1903 when the PCL crowned its first champion, the Los Angeles Angels (Bauer). Clearly, professional baseball came to the West Coast much later than it came to the East Coast (1869, as mentioned earlier), and these leagues (though popular) were not of the same level as the Majors, yet they produced Major League Level talent.
It is in this way that the PCL, and California, functioned as a microcosm for the rest of the world. The MLB spread the game to another region, which adapted the game in its own way, and then the players who learned the game moved up to the Majors. The players mentioned above, who came from California went on to influence the game profoundly. Ted Williams was, my most accounts, the greatest hitter who ever lived, and was the last Major Leaguer to bat over .400 (with .406 in 1941), which means that for every ten at bats he got a hit four times. DiMaggio was the games' first five-tool player, meaning that he combined power, speed, average, arm strength, and he was a magnificent fielder. DiMaggio's abilities changed what Major League scouts look for in players. Martin changed the way the game was played through his managerial strategy in the 1970's and 1980's. Even though these men shaped the game, none was as influential as Jackie Robinson.
Clearly Jackie Robinson paved the way for other players of color and ethnic decent to play in the Major Leagues. One of the first players to follow in Robinson's footsteps was Roberto Clemente, who was born in Puerto Rico.
Puerto Rico and the United States have long, storied ties. Puerto Rico has been a United States territory since 1900, and relations between the two regions were strong prior to 1900 (welcomtopuertorico.org). The baseball timeline in this case is of the utmost importance, as discussed above, since baseball became professionalized and widely played during the late 1800's in the United States. As baseball gained popularity in the States it was logical for expansion of the game to come through entrepreneurs and the military to Latin America (Edelman May 19, 2008). Clearly in the acquisition of a new territory to a large nation military involvement would be necessary, and so baseball was brought to Puerto Rico.
Robert Kingsbury, Clemente historian, claims that "Athletic glory in Puerto Rico was not won on the track or in the field. It was won on the baseball diamond" (Kingsbury 14). Statements such as the preceding one show how valuable and meaningful baseball is as a part of life in Puerto Rico.
One of the first players from Puerto Rico to make it to the Major Leagues was Roberto Clemente, while Clemente was not the first Puerto Rican to reach the Majors he is certainly the most prominent. Clemente had a remarkable career with the Pittsburgh Pirates that was cut short when he died tragically in a plane crash while on a humanitarian aid mission. Clemente was born in Carolina, Puerto Rico in 1934 (Kingsbury 7). When Clemente was younger he was highly influenced by the "Puerto Rican Winter League games [he listened to] on the radio" (Kingsbury 11). A weekly event that was even more influential for the young Clemente was the opportunity to see these games in person on Sundays, especially with stars such as Monte Irvin who had come over from the Negro Leagues of the United States (Kingsbury 11). Experiences such as these are the prototypical example of how young boys from Puerto Rico fell in love with the game of baseball. It is in this case alone that Clemente was not the exception to the rule, as he excelled past his peers in most every other way, and went through the normal process for a boy at the time learning and developing the game.
Clearly baseball traveled from the United States originally via the military, but as the game became popular enough to spawn players of its own the Puerto Rican Winter League developed. The invention of the Winter League provided a place for young Puerto Ricans to see stars of Major League caliber play. Eventually when these youngsters matured it provided a place for them to hone their own skills in hopes of becoming more than a sugarcane farmer, like Clemente's father (Kingsbury 7). So as baseball influenced Puerto Rico and Puerto Rican culture, Puerto Rico in turn influenced baseball. Puerto Rico has, according to baseball-reference, produced 223 Major League Baseball players (baseball-reference.com). Of recent note the "catching Molina brothers" come to mind. The three Molina brothers, Bengie, Jose, and Yadier, were all born in Puerto Rico, and have all come to play the catchers position in the Major Leagues. Perhaps more impressively is that each of the Molina brothers has won a World Series Championship. The example of the Molina brother's drive shows that Puerto Rico has clearly influenced the game of baseball as the brothers have become some of the premier players at their position.
Another interesting case study of American dominance in Latin America (though in this instance it is not a United States territory) is the Dominican Republic. Again, baseball was brought to South America via the United States military and entrepreneurs journeying to foreign nations (Edelman May 19, 2008). In the case of the Dominican Republic baseball was first brought to Cuba "in 1866 [by] American sailors" and then "migrated" to the Dominican Republic "with Cubans who were fleeing their country" (godominicanrepublic.com). Americans did not bring baseball directly to the Dominican Republic, it was brought to Cuba by Americans who then as a result of American influence after the Ten Years War brought baseball to the Dominican Republic (godominicanrepublic.com). By the end of 1891 baseball had been brought to the Dominican Republic where it would quickly catch on as a favorite pastime of the people (Klein 114). Again military influence in South America brought baseball away from its original home of the United States, and to a new country that would harbor it in a new way.
A professional baseball league was created in the Dominican Republic during the 1920's when four teams were formed (goominicanrepublic.com). Unfortunately, during the late 1930's a digressing economy forced baseball down to the amateur level again in the Dominican Republic, but this gave many players the opportunity to play against traveling teams from the United States (godominicanrepublic.com). Clearly the Dominican Republic followed in the footsteps of American predecessors in professionalizing the game. Professionalizing here means not only that the players get paid for their services, but also that the entrepreneurs who fund the teams and leagues realize that by charging admission they have the ability to turn a back alley game into a profit turning organization.
These Dominican teams helped to "latinize" the game of baseball, and inherently change it (Klein 115). The players in the Dominican Republic put a different emphasis on what was important in the game. While the American players liked "power," meaning home run hitting and strike out pitching, the Dominicans "prefer[red ...] baseball smartness and 'hustle'" (Klein 115). This type of play is indicative of the ever-evolving style currently found in the Major Leagues. When a baseball fanatic reads the words "baseball smartness and 'hustle'" one name comes to mind, the young boy from the PCL Oakland Oaks previously mentioned, Billy Martin. Billy Martin took the same type of Dominican style play and incorporated it into his ever-popular managerial style of the early 1980's with the Oakland Athletics of BillyBall. BillyBall is a type of baseball where power hitting and pitching is not relied on, instead it is about getting a solid performance from a pitcher (about 7 innings with 3 runs given up) and small ball with a designated hitter. Small ball is all about "smartness and 'hustle,'" it is about thinking three innings in advance to prevent the other manager from outsmarting you, and about always stealing the extra base when the opportunity arises. Obviously, there is something to the influx of players from Latin America and the change in managerial style that was seen afterwards.
The Dominican Republic has produced more non-United States born players than any other country. The Dominican Republic has provided the Major Leagues with 464 players (baseball-reference.com). Currently, some of baseball's greatest stars are from the Dominican Republic in Vladimir Guerrero (Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim), as well as Manny Ramirez and David Ortiz of the same Boston Red Sox as the previously mentioned Ted Williams. With players such as the aforementioned ones the Dominican Republic was the early favorite to win the aforementioned WBC, because, interestingly enough, it seems that there must have been some change in Dominican play since Klein wrote his piece, as the three players mentioned above are some of the preeminent sluggers in the game today. Another notable change in the Dominican Style of play is that none of them is particularly delicate around the base paths. However, it should be noted, that Vladimir Guerrero does play for a team which employs small ball (BillyBall) so his power hitting efforts are not used as frequently as those as Ramirez or Ortiz. Regardless of the style of baseball these players use they have had tremendous impacts on the game- Manny and Ortiz brought two championships to Boston for the first time in 100 years, and Guerrero has helped the Angels sit atop the American League West since his arrival.
Japan and the United States have had many different relationships. During the 1800's missionaries journeyed to Japan to spread religion. Then during the 1940's there were tensions because of World War Two. And now there is an economic relationship between the two nations that is commonly demonstrated during games in which Japanese stars Ichiro (of the Seattle Mariners) and Hideki Matsui (New York Yankees) have advertisements in Japanese behind home plate. The relationship between these two G7 (Group of 7 industrialized countries) nations has evolved repeatedly throughout history.
According to Joseph Reaves, author of Taking in a Game, commodore Matthew Perry ventured to Japan in 1853, thus opening the western trade routes (Reaves xv). Afterwards, during the late 1800's the YMCA and missionaries were responsible for the spread of baseball to Asia (Edelman May 19, 2008).
Japan is certainly considered to be the most baseball savvy nation outside of the United States, in large part because of the baseball ties that have been made between the two nations. During the 1930's Lefty O'Doul, a former Yankee and skipper of the San Francisco Seals of the PCL, organized many goodwill trips to Japan "to play exhibitions and teach hitting" according to Kevin Nelson, California baseball historian, and author of The Golden Game (Nelson 264). These trips made baseball much more popular in Japan, despite the fact that the game already had a large following since formal baseball teams had been organized in the country since 1878 (Reaves xv). When Pearl Harbor hit tensions between the two nations exploded, and Lefty O'Doul took it "as a personal insult" (Nelson 264). O'Doul looked past the events of Pearl Harbor and World War Two as he, and the same kid from the PCL, Joe DiMaggio, journeyed back to Japan on goodwill missions. Eventually baseball between the two nations regained sturdy grounds and former Major League greats would even go play in the Japanese Leagues towards the end of their career, perhaps most prominently was former Angels' utility man (someone who plays many different positions) Rex Hudler. This way Major League Baseball influenced Japan again, as the players showed the Japanese how the game was played in the United States via first hand accounts. Here the game changed within the already existing leagues in Japan yet again.
Now Japan has returned the favor to the United States as it has produced many Major League caliber talents, as exhibited in the World Baseball Classic. During the Classic, which Japan won, Daisuke Matsuzaka was given the honor of being named Most Valuable Player. As a result the Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees entered into a bidding war. The Red Sox (the same Red Sox of Williams, Ortiz, and Ramirez) not only won the war for Daisuke, but also the World Series with him as their number three starter in their rotation.
In this Summer Olympic year of 2008 it is nearly impossible to watch a baseball game without hearing of how the game has gained such international appeal. Historically the internationality of the game has helped spread American influence to most portions of the globe, and those regions have given back to the game in the form of the talent which they have harvested. Broadcasters on ESPN, FSN (Fox Sports Network), YES (Yankee Entertainment System), and many others speak of the reaches of baseball. Even Sports Illustrated has caught on with the hype around international players as Kosuke Fukudome (A Japanese native, and former Japanese League star) was featured as their cover boy earlier in this 2008 season. It is inherently indisputable that travel in baseball has changed the game while broadening the horizons of many players throughout the world. As the game traveled to regions within and outside of the United States it changed those areas, but most importantly those areas changed the game and the way in which it is played today. The change that these players have brought to the Majors has made the game what it currently is, the American, and the World, pastime, and the World Baseball Classic will continue to keep it that way.
WORKS CITED
Allen, Maury. Damn Yankee: The Billy Martin Story. Times Books, 1990.
"Baseball." Godominicanrepublic.com. 22 May 2008.
<http://www.godominicanrepublic.com/main.asp?xmlpath=/DominicanRepublic/About/ArtsCultureSports/Baseball/baseball_en.xml&Lang>.
Bauer, Carlos. "1903- The First PCL Champion is Crowned." Pclbaseball.com. 15 May
2008. 2002. <http://pclbaseball.com/pcl100/news/?id=3746>.
Bloom, Barry M. Venues set for World Baseball Classic. 23 March 2008. Major League
Baseball. 30 April 2008. <http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20080323&content_id=2452760&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb>.
Brown, Bill. Waging Baseball, Playing War: Games of American Imperialism. Cultural
Critique 17 (1990-1991): 51-78.
Cramer, Richard Ben. Joe DiMaggio: The Hero's Life. New York: Touchstone, 2001.
Echevarria, Roberto Gonzalez. The Pride of Havana: A History of Cuban Baseball.
Oxford University Press, 1999.
Edelman, Robert. HIEU 127, History of Sport. History of Sport. University of California,
San Diego, La Jolla, CA. 14 May 2008.
Edelman, Robert. HIEU 127, History of Sport. History of Sport. University of California,
San Diego, La Jolla, CA. 19 May 2008.
"History of Puerto Rico." Welcometopuertorico.com. 24 May 2008. 2008.
<http://welcome.topuertorico.org/history5.shtml>.
Kingsbury, Robert. Baseball Hall of Famers: Roberto Clemente. The Rosen Publishing
Group, 2003.
Klein, Alan M. "Culture, Politics, and Baseball in the Dominican Republic." Latin
American Perspectives 22.3. (1995): 111-130.
Nelson, Kevin. The Golden Game: The Story of California Baseball. Berkeley: HeyDay
Books, 2004.
"Players by Place of Birth." Baseball-Reference.com. 6 May 2008. 7 May 2008. <
http://www.baseball-reference.com/bio/>.
Reaves, Joseph A. Taking in a Game: A History of Baseball in Asia. U of Nebraska
Press, 2002.
Rosenburg, John M. The Story of Baseball. New York: Random House, 1962.
World Baseball Classic. Advertisement. The Orange County Register. 23 January 2006:
Sports 9.